Many people keep state quarters in jars and drawers without realizing some rare varieties and error strikes can be extremely valuable. This guide shows five types of state quarters that can reach values above $5,000 in the right condition, how to spot them, and what to do if you find one.
5 State Quarters Still in Circulation Worth Over $5,000 Each
This heading lists the five state quarter categories collectors most often cite as having specimens sell for over $5,000. Values depend heavily on grade, certification, and market interest, so read the identification and next-step tips carefully.
1. Wisconsin Extra Leaf Varieties (High Leaf and Low Leaf)
The 2004 Wisconsin quarter is the best-known state quarter rarity. Two distinct “extra leaf” die varieties exist: a high leaf and a low leaf near the corn stalk.
These are small die variations, but in high certified grades they can command very high prices because collectors prize them and supply in uncontaminated mint state is tiny.
- How to spot it: Look near the top right of the ear of corn for a small extra leaf pointing either up (high) or down (low).
- Why worth so much: Rarity of the die break and demand from type collectors.
2. Doubled Die State Quarter Errors
Doubled die errors occur when the die impresses the design twice with slight rotation or offset. On state quarters this can show on the date, motto, or design elements.
High-grade doubled dies that are clearly visible without magnification and that have strong provenance can sell for thousands, sometimes exceeding $5,000 for the rarest and most dramatic examples.
3. Off-Center Strikes and Major Strike Errors
Off-center strikes, broadstrikes, and large planchet errors are visually obvious and highly collectible. An off-center state quarter with a significant portion of the design missing or a large die break can reach prices above $5,000.
These pieces are valued by error collectors and general collectors alike because genuine large errors are uncommon and eye-catching.
4. Deep Cameo or PR70 Proof State Quarters
Proof quarters from the state series exist in multiple finishes. A handful of proof strikes graded PR70DCAM (perfect proof with deep cameo contrast) have sold at strong prices when tied to low production numbers or notable pedigrees.
Even circulation-struck quarters can sometimes show exceptional prooflike surfaces that earn premium grades and collector attention.
5. Highly Graded Key Dates and Low-Mintage Strikes
Some state quarters from early program years or certain mint facilities had lower survival rates in high mint state grades. A coin from a low-mintage combination that receives a high certified grade (MS67 and above) can trade for more than $5,000.
Examples include sharply struck coins with perfect surfaces and original luster that are scarce in top grades.
What Makes These State Quarters Reach Over $5,000
Several factors combine to create high values.
- Rarity of the variety or error in high grade.
- Collector demand and trends in numismatic markets.
- Certification by reputable grading services (PCGS, NGC).
- Eye appeal: strong strike, minimal contact marks, good luster.
How to Inspect a Quarter in Circulation
Use a 10x loupe and good light to check for the following features.
- Mint mark and year — note P, D, or S and the date for reference.
- Look for doubled details on the date, lettering, or design elements.
- Search for tiny extra leaf shapes on the Wisconsin quarter near the corn ear.
- Note any off-center or clipped planchet areas and large die breaks.
Record clear photos and avoid cleaning the coin. Cleaning can destroy value.
What To Do If You Find a Suspect Quarter
Follow a clear verification path to protect potential value.
- Photograph the coin with macro images of both sides.
- Compare to reference images from PCGS, NGC, or the American Numismatic Association.
- Ask a reputable coin dealer for an initial opinion — avoid auction houses or buyers who encourage cleaning.
- If promising, submit the coin to a grading service (PCGS or NGC) for certification and a definitive value.
The 50 State Quarters program ran from 1999 to 2008 and produced billions of circulation strikes. That mass production is why most quarters are common — but a few minting quirks and errors created exceptionally rare pieces.
Small Real-World Example (Case Study)
A collector checking pocket change found what looked like a normal 2004 Wisconsin quarter. Under magnification they noticed a tiny extra leaf on the corn stalk. After photographing it and consulting online references, they submitted the coin for third-party grading.
The coin received a high MS grade and was authenticated as the extra leaf variety. The graded piece sold at auction to a specialty collector. The key steps were careful documentation, avoiding cleaning, and using a reputable grading service.
Practical Tips for Everyday Searches
Keep these routines to increase your chance of spotting valuable quarters.
- Check change regularly; set aside any coin that looks unusual.
- Carry a pocket loupe or use a phone camera with macro mode for quick checks.
- Bookmark reputable numismatic variety databases and auction archives.
- Join local coin clubs or online forums for second opinions.
Finding a state quarter that could be worth over $5,000 is rare, but possible. Careful observation, documentation, and proper certification are the most important steps to unlocking that value.
If you think you have one of the five types above, start with photography and reference comparison, then contact a trusted dealer or grading service for a professional assessment.